Prof. Romila Thapar | Migrations and the Making of Cultures in Early India | Prof. Satish Chandra -1

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 дек 2024

Комментарии • 9

  • @mintusaren895
    @mintusaren895 3 года назад

    Shaping of ancient geographical demarcation.languages in that time.Rg veda depends on nature not on intellectual. Secondary received primary.Shruti and Sanskrtita.Harappa yet to rediscovered.Bargaining for Arya and Anarya.i think class smartness in society. and so on.sakta to hind to sakya kanishka. Das to dashakta. Under tribal lens especially santhal. Although you have gone through your book with others,reference yet to comment on Herodotus.and your version Ganges basin is later part of subcontinent. Vidndhyachal not matching with desert.now invation.whom to be invade by whom.reveal meaning of migration. Its my way in history.

  • @pabslondon
    @pabslondon 4 года назад +1

    Regarding 27:28 - According to the David Reich South Asian Genome study, the Iranian part of the Harappan ancestry came from Iranian Hunter Gatherers not Iranian farmers.

    • @IndianSoldierInsideBorder
      @IndianSoldierInsideBorder 3 года назад

      Indigenous hunter gatherers together with farmers

    • @dheera8889
      @dheera8889 3 года назад

      @@IndianSoldierInsideBorder the name of the leader of indigenous hunter gatherers was periyar, he later became the priest king.

  • @Konaiburhishkf
    @Konaiburhishkf 4 года назад +2

    Outstanding lecture

  • @Vin8185
    @Vin8185 4 года назад +2

    Outstanding ✨✨😍

  • @sudhakarreddy1453
    @sudhakarreddy1453 3 года назад

    Whether one likes it or not -- Aryans happened to be the Victors -- and hence the *dasyas* or Dravidians became the victims !!
    If all the people were Aryans , then why is it that Sanskrit did not become the language of all the people????

    • @IndianSoldierInsideBorder
      @IndianSoldierInsideBorder 3 года назад

      True brother

    • @dheera8889
      @dheera8889 3 года назад

      Why the Farsi didn't become language of North India despite farsi remained language of courts of Delhi sultanat and mugal empire for centuries. Things don't work according to your stupid logic.